Sunset Key Cottages

This was our 6th time at Sunset Key Cottages and it was another wonderful vacation. The entire staff was friendly and accommodating as always. We met Chris Quay the general manager and Ashley in Sales and Catering. They were both fantastic and Ashley helped me surprise my husband on his birthday like she did last year. Our cottage was perfect as always. We love going into town to spend part of the day and coming back and sitting on the porch and watching the boats go by. You can't ask for a more relaxing trip. Thanks again to everyone at Sunset Key Cottages and we will be back!

My husband and I came here for the first time 25 years ago. It was a trip that always stuck with me and I always wanted to get back. I saw over the years that management had changed and I wondered what it was like. Decided to try it again for spring break with our girls as our oldest daughter was going to meet us from her college and we needed to stay in the country. Wow. What a pleasant surprise. We stayed in the same oceanfront cottage that we had years ago. But they changed the restaurant (it's so lovely) and the island was now finished with all the cottages complete and then there is a section with very nice homes. We loved every minute of it. Relaxed, quiet, well kept, and an overall very lovely experience. We will be back.

Having lived in Florida for over 50 years my wife and I very much appreciate its many charms. In fact, we often have said we live in Paradise. So is it possible for there to be a Paradise in Paradise? The question never arose until our visit to Sunset Key Cottages and the answer is a gigantic YES! Traveling via the resort’s ferry from Key West to Sunset Key is an instant mood changer - much like crossing the bridge into Brigadoon! The scenic beauty of the short journey being very much facilitated by the ebullient dock staff and ferry crew. Upon disembarking and advancing onto the island the mood continues to become more serene as one observes the perfectly manicured property and the architecture style that the landscaping so beautifully complements. The entire resort presents as a neighborhood where one would very much enjoy living. But wait, there’s more! We were escorted to our accommodations by Andre, who instantly realized an alternative was needed due to my wife’s health issue. The change was seamless and very much unexpected. When he was joined by an associate, and we replied to them that we were having a birthday dinner at the resort’s top notch Latitudes restaurant that evening, they spontaneously sang Happy Birthday to her! We have celebrated many occasions at top-notch resorts all over Florida and that is a FIRST! Our entire stay unfolded with continued excellent appreciation by all staff of our being guests at Sunset Key Cottages wherever we were in the Resort. In addition, every food option of every type is top shelf. Whether it be breakfast at Latitudes, lunch poolside at Flippers, a stunning sunset dinner at Latitudes, or in-room service, there are cuisine options to satisfy the most discerning diner. Even if one just wanted a snack, the kitchen is fully stocked with a variety of beverages in the refrigerator, coffee maker, tea and packaged snacks too – all complimentary. The young ones are not forgotten. The resort provides many entertainment options if you are traveling with children. Probably the most popular is the ice cream cooler on a tricycle with the ice cream man ringing the bell to alert the little ones to come get their treat! To be clear, having stayed at every top-notch resort in the Keys, including coming in on our boat over a 2 decade period, and hosting a destination wedding at one 12 years ago, we believe that Sunset Key Cottages is at another level. We will return soon.

Absolutely paradise!!! Would definitely stay here again. From the time we got on the boat to the island until the time we left, we were treated with kindness, courtesy, and a luxurious experience. The staff members were all above and beyond helpful in any request we made. We dined at latitudes and the pool bar several times and the food and service were excellent. We enjoyed just sitting on our porch, taking in the view of Key West, which was so peaceful. We enjoyed the pool and hot tub areas also. A special touch in the cottages were the fresh and crisp robes and slippers provided to us. The daily breakfast and evening goodie baskets were delicious and so appreciated. Just an overall relaxing and enjoyable vacation.

The Finesse Experience was so amazing!! The Pilates was the best thing to do if you need to stretch, + workout + relaxation, I totally recommend it! It is earlier in the morning so the weather is perfect. You have to try the Pilates before you leave

Jazzy elevates the meaning of welcome to the island….always a big smile coupled with laughter….knowing everyone’s name…on his day off brought my wife balloons and serenaded her at dinner….all a surprise!!!….he is such an asset to the island and is everyone’s rock star....he is the BEST