Come As You Are Inn LLC

On LI for my nephew's February 22 wedding in Babylon, my wife and I  spent 6 nights at Come As You Are. We really appreciated Innkeepers Mark and Ari’s attention to detail which made our stay so pleasant. The Mae West Room upstairs was very comfortable with a fireplace and lots of light. Downstairs the ambient music was great as was Mark's piano playing (he is an accomplished church organist). We enjoyed freshly baked treats each day and engaging conversations with Mark and Ari, pretty much like being with friends. Plus they extended the friendship with delightful baked goodies for us to take on the flight home. The way we arrived at staying at Come As You Are is while looking through the abundance of chain hotels, it became apparent that mostl got mediocre to poor reviews. We said, surely we can find better. A little digging paid off and we discovered Come As You Are. Highly recommended on every level.

We had a lovely weekend with Mark and Ari. We enjoyed wonderful conversations while eating yummy breakfast every morning. They were so kind and willing to drive us around. The location was great to walk to town or take the ferry to Fire Island. Can’t wait to come back!

This place is perfect! Cozy, spotless, well-appointed, up-to-date. Hosts Ari and Mark are gracious, thoughtful, welcoming. The continental breakfast is astoundingly good, everything homemade: bread, popovers, even the jams. And the pool! Spectacular. Surrounded by classy slate tile and comfortable seating. Also full bar. Highly recommended!